Okay, so lolikit and IcyStorm have decided to become innocent anime heroines and try to become “kindness, care, love, beauty, cheerfulness, friendliness.” In summary, they’re going to look past the “not wonderful” world of ours, trying to find the proverbial silver lining. They want to look past all the bad things to see the good aspects of events in their lives and in others.
I’m as full of kindness and care as anyone, but I not only think that being kind/caring 100% of the time is not possible; I think it is a bad idea. It’s as natural for people to be uncaring as it is for them to be caring. Don’t forget that “not caring” is the same thing as general apathy in some instances. It’s necessary that people realize that not everyone loves them or cares for them. This makes the ones that do all the more meaningful.
Their experiment isn’t actually about “loving” people. It seems to be geared toward showing a simple respect and good outlook. Oddly, the criteria they intend to follow doesn’t seem all that stringent. The one main problem is that the goal is essentially anti-conflict in nature.
Humans still live in a world in which we compete for “resources,” even at a local level. The concept of “resources” can be abstracted anywhere from a mate to a good seat at the movie theater. Basically, what I’m getting at is, conflict too is in the nature of us. We need to conflict in order to grow, to learn, and to prosper. Ask yourself, why does humanity strive for any goal? What is the purpose of our civilizations? Finally, what was the driving force behind that growth? I think you’ll find the answer quite obvious.
A quote from a book I read a long time ago comes to mind, Everyday Ethics by Joshua Halberstam:
Imagine a world where your behavior is never evaluated: no one ever praises you, no one ever criticizes you. Whenever you do something wrong, people say, “Ah, you know how she is, you can’t really blame her. If you knew about her upbringing, you’d understand.” Most people hate to be excused in that dismissive manner. We want people to hold us responsible for what we do, even if that means ticking them off. We would much prefer to have people angry with us than have them pity us.
Judging other people’s actions is rooted in conflict. That particular passage of the book goes on to talk about how condescending not judging other people is, showing a disrespect of that person.
People have a right to be punished. They have a right to be treated like adults, not like children or animals. When you refuse to judge someone, you refuse to take that person seriously.
With regard to lolikit and Icystorm’s experiment, while the goal is admirable, I think the method is flawed.